This haunting true crime documentary is like a horror story come to life

True crime has long fascinated viewers and invited them into the darkest depths of the human psyche. Occasionally a story comes along in this genre that resembles a fictional Hollywood blockbuster and sends shivers down your spine. Without a doubt the stranger story of the infamous French fraudster Frederick Bourdinwho brazenly posed as a missing Texas teenager Nicholas Barclay in 1997, fits this bill. In 1994, thirteen-year-old Barclay went missing from his parents' home in San Antonio, Texas, prompting his family to report the matter to authorities. Three years later he is said to have miraculously reappeared in Spain. How the teenager crossed the Atlantic remained a mystery, and weeks later his family brought Bourdin, claiming to be Barclay, from Madrid to their home in Texas. Bourdin, a fraudster already wanted by Interpol for similar crimes, used his trickery experience to beat the Spanish judicial system, American authorities, the press and, believe it or not, Barclay's own family members to prove that he it was indeed her long lost relatives.

The impostora 2012 documentary by the British filmmaker Bart Laytonchronicles this unconscionable criminal event. It is a well-made documentary that would be considered great fiction if the events depicted in it were not entirely true.The impostor is like a horror film come to life.

“The Imposter” features its true crime characters

Frédéric Bourdin, the alleged anti-hero, and his victims, with the exception of the missing Barclay, are all part of the film and give first-hand accounts of the events. In the Barclay family we have Barclay's sister Carey Gibsonhis mother Beverly Dollarhidehis nephew Codey Gibsonand brother-in-law Bryan Gibson all represented. Also part of the film are law enforcement officers, the (former) US Consul General in Spain Philip FrenchPrivate detective Charlie Parkerand FBI agent Nancy Fischer. While we already know how the story will end in this disturbing documentary (the film gives it away from the start, and the title of the documentary gives it away anyway), Bart Layton structures his narrative in a way that leaves you wanting more. Featuring a mix of structured interviews and dramatized re-enactments Bourdin directs the narrative, creating a basis for the chronology of events. Other characters are brought in expertly and in a timely manner to add depth to the story, giving their version of events at different stages. Bart Layton carefully handles each of these real-life characters to keep you informed.

The impostor begins with the bizarre scene of a homeless Bourdin in Madrid, Spain, calling the police from a phone booth and falsely claiming to have found a lost child. When the police arrive, they find him curled up in the cabin, pretending to be that child, and he is taken to a nursing home. There he hatches a plan to pose as another actual missing child in hopes of finding refuge. Bourdin's plan fails when he learns of Barclay's disappearance. However, there is one big problem: he has nothing to do with the American teenager. He speaks English with an accent, has brown eyes and dark hair, while Barclay had blue eyes and blonde hair, has no tattoos and is seven years older than Barclay. In his own words, “The only thing he had in common with me was five fingers on one hand.” Bourdin does his best to transform himself into this character he has never met and doesn't know. He tells the FBI that he was kidnapped by military men and forced into a sex trafficking ring, where he was tortured before escaping. It works, and with “his sister” in tow, he boards a plane to her home in San Antonio.

One of Bourdin's earliest lines sets the pace for the rollercoaster ride to come:

Before I was born I definitely had the wrong identity. I already didn't know – I was already prepared for not knowing who I really was. A new identity with a real passport, an American passport. I could go to the US, go to school there, live with this family and just be someone and never have to worry about being identified again. I saw the opportunity.

This chilling introduction to his manipulative nature and his willingness to go the extra mile to exploit others' vulnerabilities is a foretaste of the psychological horror story in the documentary. The horror lies not only in the deception, but also in the realization that on the screen we have a real, amoral person who only cares about himself and nothing stands between him and his goal.

“The Imposter” is a horror story with a twist

The impostor evokes horror without focusing on the brutality of the crime itself. It explores how criminals manipulate the truth for their own selfish purposes. If you're hoping for a story with a happy ending, The impostor debunks this from the start and explains that what you are about to see is a well-calculated and successful scam. As opposed to Creating a murderer or The stairsThe impostor is an intimate excavation of the human element. The examination of the emotional and psychological effects experienced by the victims – the internal rather than the external – is similar to classic horror films Alfred Hitchcock Psycho. The tension arises from both the characters' internal struggles and external threats. The film raises many unanswered questions: Why can't the family see the seemingly obvious differences between their prodigal son and the imposter? Are they so desperate to get their son back that anything or anyone would be a worthy consolation? Is there more than meets the eye, as the film seems to suggest that the family may be hiding something more sinister? Or is it just because the family has been through so much heartache that accepting Bourdin is the innate human tendency to believe and hope for the best? Bart Layton's creative choices will keep you hooked until the end, hoping to find answers to these questions.

Which adds to the eerie feeling The impostorS The action that the story already contains takes place in Barclay's house in San Antonio, Texas. Revelations from neighbors about frequent violent confrontations in the home, the apparent apathy of some family members toward Bourdin even after it was revealed that he was not related to them, investigators suspecting an even more sinister incident, and Bourdin making bold, dark claims about the family sets up, leaving them behind He wondered if his acceptance into the home was a desperate attempt to redeem them. But for what purpose? Barclay's real footage filmed before his disappearance and used throughout the documentary, creates an unsettling, ghostly presence in the film. It's like he's witnessing everything that's said in the film.

Bart Layton optimizes the use of narrative and documentary elements in “The Imposter”

Just like in a traditional movie, Layton's direction uses elements that manipulate the viewer's emotions. He cleverly withholds information that he reveals at crucial moments in the story. Still, he uses traditional documentary-style interviews, in which subjects relay exactly that information in a fluid manner that he rearranges for the story. This creates an exciting viewing experience that is similar to a traditional film. His creative decision is that tension is not the focus If Bourdin is exposed, however When. This allows the film to focus on the core of the story. He addresses the challenges of his characters, such as Bourdin's obstacles. How can he be considered a sixteen-year-old blue-eyed boy when he is a 23-year-old man with brown eyes? Will he convince Barclay's family that he is their relative? When and how will the private detective find out about this? Beyond Bourdin's perspective, the other characters' narrations help fill in the gaps, leaving just enough unresolved at every twist to keep you hooked.

The extreme close-ups used in the documentary provide an intimate atmosphere that allows viewers to directly interact with the subjects on screen. For example, Bourdin's direct narration reveals his lack of conscience, while the Barclay family's unfiltered feelings personalize the story. Because Layton arranges the themes against a simple and clear backdrop, the focus remains on the story, while the light score does not distract or overly sentimentalize the narrative. His combination of these interviews with clever re-enactments in which we rarely see the actors' faces paints a stunning phantom image of the true events the documentary depicts.

Dealing with the topics of personal identity and family psychology, The impostor poses the question: Is our truth nothing more than carefully constructed illusions? This documentary, whose reality can be more frightening than most horror films, is not just a story about a con artist – It is a reflection of our deepest vulnerabilities and the lengths we go to to escape them.

The impostor is now available to stream on Prime Video in the US

WATCH ON Prime